War and Tweets

Terrorism in America in the Digital Age

Since 9/11, 147 people in America have died in terrorist attacks, including 94 at the hands of jihadists. And while U.S. officials say they have prevented many other attacks, it is simply not possible to stop them all, especially in a society that depends on the freedom of movement of ideas, information, capital, and people. 

This paper examines the changing context for public reactions to terrorism in America, particularly the evolving role of the news media in shaping those reactions and the rising, powerful influence of social media. The Pulse nightclub attack in Orlando is considered as a case study for how government decisions, political rhetoric, and especially news and social media shape public reactions to terrorist attacks and ultimately build civic resilience to terrorism. Leaders in Orlando did many things right in a difficult, tragic, and chaotic situation, and their actions can serve as an example for other cities. 

Authors Sharon Burke, Alyssa Sims, and David Sterman present five policy recommendations based on their study of the Pulse nightclub attack and the response of Orlando city officials, journalists, social media, and the public.

  1. Leadership Matters. Even in an era when social media can define a story before traditional media or government officials can even comment, officials and law enforcement remain an authoritative source of information in a crisis. 
  2. Give the Public a Constructive Role. Orlando Mayor Buddy Dyer and other city officials gave the people of Orlando a way to be something other than victims of terrorism, focusing them on positive emotions, rather than fear and anger.
  3. Include Communications and Social Media Use in Exercises and Planning—and Real Life. Law enforcement and city officials actively used social media to shape press coverage and directly reach the public, disseminating news as quickly and widely as possible. The city had included strategic communications in disaster planning efforts.
  4. Empower Local Press. As members of the community themselves, local reporters and editors play a particularly important role in public resilience and recovery. 
  5. Social Media Companies Should Embrace Responsibility. These companies should acknowledge the de facto role they are playing as the mass media of choice for many people and be proactive about adopting standards and responsibilities.  

Civic resilience to terrorism should be a public policy priority and the responsibility of city governments, law enforcement officials, journalists, social media companies, and members of the public, who ultimately get to choose how they react to an attack. Orlando offers one example of how a community can successfully choose to be resilient.

Editor's Note: October 27, 2016—This paper has been updated with additional citations and sourcing, and to update the number of annual visitors to Orlando. The city received 66 million visitors in 2015, which is the most recent data.

ATTACHMENT:

War and Tweets - Updated 10/27/16

Authors:

Sharon E. Burke is a senior advisor at New America, where she focuses on international security and a new program, Resource Security, which examines the intersection of security, prosperity, and natural resources.

Alyssa Sims is a program associate with the International Security program at New America.

David Sterman is a policy analyst in New America's International Security program. He holds a master's degree from Georgetown’s Center for Security Studies.