Vicki Shabo
Senior Fellow for Gender Equity, Paid Leave & Care Policy and Strategy, Better Life Lab
State Progress Should Help Spur Federal Action on Paid Leave
Since 2004, July 1 has been a significant day for working families and the movement to make paid family and medical leave available to every working person in the United States. As I explained to Congress earlier this year, workers' access to paid leave is deeply connected to their health, economic security and well-being and that of their families, to the stability and security of businesses, and to reducing health and economic disparities across race, ethnicity, gender and income levels. Workers’, families’ and employers’ experiences during the COVID-19 pandemic only underscore its importance.
California’s and New Jersey’s first- and second-in-the-nation paid family leave programs took effect on July 1, 2004 and 2009, respectively, and have served millions of people. And today, July 1, 2020, marks new milestones for these states as their programs implement improved benefits. It is also a milestone for the District of Columbia (D.C.), which has implemented an entirely new program and, today, joins California, New Jersey, New York, Rhode Island and Washington state in guaranteeing paid family and medical leave to working people; Massachusetts (Jan. 2021), Connecticut (Jan. 2022) and Oregon (Jan. 2023) will soon follow suit. From each of these states' experiences, we are learning how equitable wage replacement, employment protections and coverage for a range of family care relationships can help close the gaps and make leave available, accessible and affordable to everyone.
Two new explainers from New America’s Better Life Lab summarize how these programs work and how they build on federal Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) protections and one another:
Many more details about each aspect of state laws are available in our new explainers on program coverage and funding and benefits and in these excellent resources from the National Partnership for Women & Families and A Better Balance.
The COVID-19 crisis makes even more clear than before that paid family and medical leave is an essential protection, one which too few workers have and tens of millions of people need. Had the United States had a paid leave program in place when the pandemic struck, working people and employers would have been better and more quickly able to manage the health and care needs that arose. Urban Institute analysis of California and Rhode Island paid family and medical leave claims data shows that state paid leave programs in those states were able to absorb new claims and provide financial security to workers there, without imposing unexpected new costs.
In response to COVID-19, Congress enacted limited, temporary measures to address some workers' need for paid time off to deal with the illness and new child care needs. These limited measures should be expanded to more cover all workers, for more reasons, and for a longer period of time. Paid leave will be essential in helping workers, families, customers and employers navigate the next 12-18+ months of uncertainty.
However, the United States also needs a permanent national solution to address a fuller range of personal health and family caregiving needs. State progress has paved the way for a national paid family and medical leave program that covers everyone, no matter where they live, the job they hold, or the care to a new child, loved one or themselves that they need to give or receive.