Zahava Stadler
Director, Education Funding Equity
New State Lawmakers Have More Power Over the Program Than They Think. They Should Use It To Safeguard Students and Educational Quality.
The new Federal Scholarship Tax Credit (FSTC), signed into law as part of the 2025 Republican reconciliation bill, will go into effect in 2027. The program provides federal subsidies for select elementary and secondary education costs, but with several intermediate steps. First, individual taxpayers make donations to eligible, nonprofit scholarship-granting organizations (SGOs).1 Those SGOs use the money to give scholarships to students for a wide range of elementary and secondary education expenses, from private school tuition to supplemental services to activity fees.2 The so-called “donors” are fully reimbursed for up to $1,700 in qualified contributions in the form of tax credit, so all the cost is ultimately borne by the federal budget. For more on the program, including serious concerns about its design, see this companion post.
State leaders must choose whether their states will take part by January 1. Leaders in over 30 states have already decided to participate in the first year. The law presents this as the one decision point for states: an on-off switch, rather than a dimmer. Though state leaders have signaled an interest in making the program more targeted, the proposed IRS regulations instead offer a litany of all the things they may not do. They may not create their own requirements for SGOs. They may not narrow the program to support particular groups of students, such as students from low-income backgrounds or those in public schools. They may not limit the eligible uses of scholarship dollars.
But states do have general powers that are relevant. They oversee private schools, pass and enforce consumer protection laws that apply to for-profit education service companies, and set policies around public school funding. If a state is going to participate in the FSTC, its leaders need to use these tools to make sure that the program doesn’t become a funnel of unaccountable public dollars that undermine educational quality and resource equity. Here are a few ideas.
About 9 percent of K-12 students attend private schools, a number that is likely to go up if the FSTC becomes a big source of support for tuition. But most states have fairly lax rules for these schools. The organization EdChoice, which promotes private school choice, notes that most states require private schools to be registered (34) and/or licensed (38), but only half (25) require that they be state-approved. Accreditation is optional in a majority of states (35) and can often be given by a third party rather than the state. Standardized testing requirements are spotty. The U.S. Department of Education reports that only about half of states require private schools to cover core subjects, and only eight require teachers to be certified in all private schools.
This hands-off approach has costs. As I explained in a companion post, private schools in America are not all high-achieving prep schools. The most common type of private school in America, according to Harris and Olivier (2025), charges just $5,000 a year in tuition and enrolls about 30 students. And small, low-quality schools with uncertified teachers and poor educational offerings are not difficult to start. They could easily become a growth industry for providers looking to tap into scholarship dollars.
States that supercharge their private school sectors by opting into the FSTC have an ethical obligation to step up oversight. The program rules are clear that FSTC funds can be used for expenses related to school enrollment or attendance, with “school”–this is key–defined according to state law. A private school that can’t meet reasonable quality and content requirements shouldn’t qualify. States should put in place clear criteria for state approval of new private schools, require robust accreditation, mandate instruction in core subjects, and assess academic achievement.
In some states, private schools can be run for profit. But the for-profit education industry is much broader than those schools; many FSTC dollars will go to companies that provide educational services and products. IRS rules for the program aren’t final, but it appears likely that parents will pay for, and be reimbursed by scholarships for, tutoring and test preparation, curricular materials, electronic devices and learning software, extracurricular activities, college admissions counseling, and independent educational assessments and therapies. Some of these businesses will be reputable and have high-value offerings. Many others will not. And families will have little guidance in figuring out which is which.3
States already have laws on the books to protect consumers from fraudulent or deceptive business practices. They must act to strengthen and enforce those laws against FSTC vendors that prey on families with inflated claims about academic impact, service or product quality, or staff qualifications. If they don’t, this program could easily become a gold mine for educational charlatans.
Many public school advocates hope to see public school districts benefit from these scholarship dollars. As we discuss in a companion post, they almost certainly will, at least to an extent; students enrolled in public schools can receive scholarships, and some will use them to pay their districts for fee-based offerings, like after-school programs and extracurricular activities. But public schools in wealthy neighborhoods are likely to see the most benefit from the program.
Why? First, schools will need to work for this money. They’ll have to create or partner with SGOs that can award scholarships to their students; encourage staff and community members to donate; and perhaps even begin to charge fees for services that were once free, such as in-school tutoring, just so that they can collect scholarship payments. Given the effort involved, schools in wealthier areas are more likely to have the staff, know-how, and volunteer capacity to take best advantage of the program.
Second, there are more potential donors in high-income communities. An analysis from the Brookings Institution projects that, given what we know about similar state programs, public schools in the richest counties are likely to get the most scholarship dollars. And there is ample precedent for this concern. As we know from research on PTA fund-raising, donor-dependent education dollars tend to benefit schools in wealthier neighborhoods the most.
One way for a state to address the FSTC’s inequities is to counterbalance them through the school funding system. States almost always have a way of accounting for local wealth in their school funding formulas; districts with higher property values are expected to raise more of their school funding from local sources, while lower-wealth districts see more of their budgets covered by state aid. Why should states allow the FSTC to undermine this effort at fairness? If the scholarship dollars follow the expected, inequitable pattern, states could count scholarship dollars as part of the district’s “local wealth” and subtract a commensurate amount of state aid–or at least, a substantial percentage of that amount–and use the savings to boost funding in higher-need districts. The same could be done within districts: if the individual schools in the district that serve the highest-income families wind up receiving the most scholarship money, districts could use that opportunity to redirect funding to their other campuses.
Despite serious problems with the program’s design, most states have opted to take part in 2027. Some governors are true believers in school choice in almost any form, while others are just excited about a new funding stream in constrained times. But even policymakers who are enthusiastic about the program should be less excited about its likely downsides: students receiving substandard private educations; fraudulent businesses preying on parents of scholarship students; and scholarship payments that undermine states’ efforts at funding fairness. The good news is that state policymakers have more power than they may think. By using the tools at their disposal–starting with oversight of private schools, enforcement of consumer protection laws, and equitable school funding policies–states that want to participate in the program can still act to blunt its worst unintended consequences.