In Short

Is Trump’s “Free Money” for K–12 Education Worth the Cost? Twenty-One New Governors Will Have to Decide

Stacks of twenty dollar bills pass through a machine during the printing process
Getty Images

Election day 2026 saw a wave of new leaders elected at the state level. Nine states saw major changes in partisan legislative control, and twenty-one new governors will take office this January. Also new in 2027: the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit (FSTC), a pipeline of federal money that will begin to subsidize some families’ education expenditures. But the FSTC, created as part of the 2025 Republican reconciliation bill, is not automatically a nationwide program. Each governor, or another designated state entity, must choose annually if their state will participate by the first of January. 

At least 30 states have already announced their intention to participate. The program has been welcomed by some officials as “free money.” Others have seen it differently–like Virginia Governor Abigail Spanberger, who just reversed her predecessor’s decision to opt in because the FSTC would send public dollars to private schools. Now, a new set of leaders will have to choose whether the program will operate in their state. Will they see the program as a positive for their students? Or will they follow Governor Spanberger’s lead and say no?

How the Program Works

Taxpayers can donate money to eligible, nonprofit scholarship-granting organizations (SGOs). Up to $1,700 per donor per year will be reimbursed by the federal government, dollar for dollar, in the form of a tax credit (making the money less of a donation and more of a loan). An SGO can then give scholarships of any size to almost any student. The money can be spent on a huge range of costs that a family might incur in connection with a child’s elementary or secondary education, including private school tuition, supplemental programs or activities, house calls from therapists, or even a home computer.1

The Federal Government is Writing a Blank Check

Let it be said: This is not a well designed policy. Private entities–donors and nonprofits–will direct public money mostly to private providers of educational services and products, including for-profit businesses. This will happen with no public deliberation, prioritization, or quality control. And the amount to be spent in this unaccountable way has no cap, making it a large, open-ended federal funding commitment disguised as tax policy–potentially larger than many programs that have actual, defined appropriations. Unlike most other federal funding for K-12 education, the program is not targeted to the students with the greatest needs. Instead, the income threshold for qualified  recipients is very high, to the point that boosters of the FSTC gleefully report that upwards of 85 percent of school-aged children in every state will be eligible, whether they need the help or not.

Will This Program Provide New Money to Public School Districts?

Because the rules are so expansive, some have expressed the hope that the new program could be a helpful source of revenue for public school districts. Scholarship money certainly can be used for family expenses related to a public school student’s education; that’s clear in the law. How much it will provide for districts, though, is yet to be seen. My prediction is that this is likely to be a smaller portion of the spending that flows through the program, especially initially. 

Scholarships can only be used for expenses that families incur. To state the obvious, private schools charge tuition, and can accept scholarship payments for that big-ticket expense. Public schools don’t and can’t. They are legally obligated to provide students, including students with resource-intensive needs, with a free, public education. They can only charge for extras, like extracurricular activities, after-school care, and extended-year programs. That limits what scholarship payments they can receive. And even when a public school student receives a scholarship, that money is given to the student, not the school; they could pay the school for a fee-based activity, but they are just as likely to spend it on private tutoring. (The tutoring could be beneficial for the student! But that scholarship will still not provide any revenue to the district.)

Private schools have a big head start, since so many already have affiliated nonprofit organizations that provide scholarships to their students. Public school districts could follow suit, attempting to partner with nonprofit organizations that will grant scholarships specifically for their students to pay for supplemental offerings. But there’s no guarantee that this money will be truly additive. State budgets are tight, and some lawmakers may use the federally funded scholarship as an excuse to cut or freeze state aid for public schools.

What About the Money That Will Pay for Private School Tuition?

Scholarship dollars used for private school tuition do not necessarily unlock a better education. First, data from several state programs shows that a majority of school voucher recipients are already in private schools; the money subsidizes existing private school students more than it provides broader access. When families get public subsidies for private school tuition, like vouchers and education savings accounts, private schools have tended to raise tuition, limiting the benefits to students from low-income backgrounds. Private schools are also not open to all children; not only can they pick and choose their students, but many also discriminate against students who are LGBTQ or disabled.  

Even if students get access to private schools, that does not guarantee a quality education. In important research published last year, economists Douglas Harris and Gabriel Olivier described the private school landscape. Contrary to the stereotype of high-cost, high-achieving prep schools, they find that the most common type of private school in America charges $5,000 a year in tuition (less than a third of the amount of per-pupil spending in public schools), serves about 30 students in total, and is likely to meet in a church basement. The U.S. Department of Education reports that relatively few states require private schools to be accredited or their teachers to be credentialed. Fewer than half mandate a curriculum that covers core subjects. Religious schools often have even fewer requirements.

This laxity raises two concerns. First, students using the FSTC to enroll in private schools may very well get a worse education as a result. Second, given the low bar for what constitutes a private school in the United States, the program could incentivize the creation of new, low-quality private schools that will subsist primarily on scholarship dollars. Investigative journalists at Propublica recently demonstrated how easy it is to do so by officially registering new private schools in three states despite a total lack of education qualifications. 

Of course, there are many good private schools as well, and some students will use scholarship dollars to attend those. But since any private school will be eligible to receive an enrolled student’s scholarship dollars, and since scholarship determinations will be made entirely by independent SGOs, there is real risk that publicly funded scholarships will be funneled to schools that are little more than diploma mills.

State Leaders (Current and Incoming) Have Some Decisions to Make

Proposed IRS regulations have given the impression that opting in or out is the only decision that state leaders can make about the program. After all, as this post from the Learning Policy Institute helpfully summarizes, the IRS did not allow states to add their own operational requirements for SGOs, direct that scholarships be awarded to specific categories of students, or narrow the list of eligible expenditures. SGOs, not states, are meant to be the decision-makers.

But in a program with serious potential for poor use of public funds, state leaders who do opt into this program have an obligation to use all available tools to ensure quality, transparency, and fairness. In a companion post, we describe some of the ways that state lawmakers should exercise their regulatory and oversight powers to blunt any negative effects of this very loose policy.

More About the Author

Citations
  1. The rules for eligible expenditures are the same as those for the elementary and secondary education expenses that can be made with Coverdell savings account funds, which are codified in 26 U.S. Code § 530.
Is Trump’s “Free Money” for K–12 Education Worth the Cost? Twenty-One New Governors Will Have to Decide