A Closer Look at the Lower Mekong Region

lower-mekong-region.png

Population dynamics, economic indicators, government models, pursuits of cooperation and competition, and the complexities of outside involvement are foundational elements to consider when gauging the region’s potential for digital transformation.

More than 245 million people live in the Lower Mekong Region. Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, Thailand, and Vietnam are connected by the Mekong River, which drives the region’s extraordinary agricultural and fishery productivity and provides the economic livelihood for tens of millions of people. Even as the region modernizes away from the dominance of river-powered economies, the countries remain deeply connected. Altogether, there is a reliance on foreign direct investment and assistance, export-focused production and manufacturing, travel and tourism revenue, trade, agritech, education, and sustainability measures.

While there is a wide variety of development and digital transformation across the five countries, Thailand and Vietnam tend to follow similar paths of development and capacity with significant urban populations and advanced commercial and innovation pursuits. Cambodia and Laos follow behind with larger percentages of rural populations and a stronger reliance on foreign investment and aid. Myanmar’s development has regressed since the military coup in February 2021.

Population

Demographic trends in the Lower Mekong Region are marked by increased urbanization, with the region’s populations generally skewing younger and slightly more female. The region’s population growth is characterized by substantial urbanization driven by economic development, which has led to greater access to modern healthcare and longer life expectancies. Most growth is centered in urban areas where there is greater access to education and jobs. The age breakdown across the region skews younger than other regions, as approximately a fifth of the population is under the age of 14. The population over the age of 65 is lower in the Lower Mekong Region than the average across Asia. Recent data shows that in Cambodia, Myanmar, Thailand, and Vietnam, women tend to slightly outnumber men.

Economic Development

The World Bank classifies each country in the region as a “Lower Middle Income Country” (LMIC)—except for Thailand, which is an “Upper Middle Income Country.” In recent years, these economies have been increasingly powered by manufacturing, strong export markets, and urbanization, resulting in an elevation in living standards for many. Thailand and Vietnam have seen greater poverty alleviation than Cambodia, Laos, and Myanmar, in part because the two countries are industrializing at a rapid pace, as demonstrated in Table 1. Both nations have focused on high-tech manufacturing in hopes of avoiding the “middle income trap.” This happens when a nation’s development stalls because its major industries revolve around producing basic goods that face extensive global competition instead of higher-technology goods that require greater skills and technical expertise. Over the past twenty years, both Thailand and Vietnam have doubled the concentration of high-technology production as a share of manufacturing. In comparison, both Cambodia and Laos have lost some share over the last twenty years.

Government Models

Forms of public administration vary across the region, but all populations are navigating increasingly authoritarian governments. Laos and Vietnam are communist states with single-party rule. Thailand is a constitutional monarchy. Cambodia is more complicated, with a self-defined multiparty democracy under a constitutional monarchy. Myanmar has been under a series of dictatorships since 1962, with a brief semi-parliamentary democracy period from 2010 to 2020, and has been under military rule since a 2021 coup. While there are different forms of government in the region, none of the countries are considered to be open and free societies with strong legal protections of individual liberties and political rights per human rights watchdog organization Freedom House. See Table 2 for each country’s Internet Freedom Scores from Freedom House.

Competing Global Influences

Geopolitical influences play an outsized role in how this region cooperates internally and with other global players. Countries in this region are often pushed and pulled in different geopolitical directions, making them accustomed to balancing external pressures and influence against internal development priorities. Sources of foreign direct investment often help shape and drive government priority areas for development and action in the region, which are further complicated when navigating competing outside influences surrounding technological advancements. As one international cyber policy expert noted when interviewed, some of the Lower Mekong governments are hesitant to partner with China despite the attractiveness of Chinese foreign investment due to suspicions of strings-attached deals and incidents of hacking and surveillance. Conversely, the same governments are also wary of partnering with Western nations, given the democracy-related obligations and expectations that come with development money.

United States

Beyond the longstanding cultural, historical, and political ties, there are deep innovation and commercial links between the United States and the Lower Mekong Region. The United States is the top trading partner for Thailand and Vietnam. Enhancing U.S. ties with this region is a priority of President Joe Biden’s administration. U.S. foreign assistance to the subregion totaled more than $4.3 billion over the past 12 years. There are over 1,000 U.S. companies active in the region, with many U.S. companies looking to decrease their manufacturing costs and dependencies, strategically navigate tariffs on goods, diversify their supply chains, and identify new customers.1 The U.S.-based Big Tech giants—Amazon, Apple, Google, Meta, and Microsoft—are active in the region, offering popular platforms, e-commerce, gaming, products, cloud services, and jobs at regional office hubs and manufacturing sites. Facebook (Meta) is often the only internet known in some regional communities. Apple has diversified production lines to be less dependent on China, many AirPods Pro are now stamped with: “Designed by Apple in California. Assembled in Vietnam.” In addition, one of the largest high-tech investments in Vietnam is from a U.S. company, Intel, which has invested nearly $1.5 billion to build a state-of-the-art chip assembly and test manufacturing facility in Saigon Hi-Tech Park, creating thousands of jobs.2

China

Despite periodic strained political relations, China and the five countries share natural resources, trade ties, and investment for major traditional and digital infrastructure systems. While China is highly influential across the Lower Mekong, international conflicts—such as the South China Sea dispute—and other political and economic divides drive tensions in the region. In fact, the administration of the Mekong River is a particular concern, complicated by allegations that upriver dams in China are negatively affecting the health of the Mekong downriver. China continues to participate in the Greater Mekong Subregion Economic Cooperation Program, created in 1992 with support from the Asian Development Bank. In addition, China remains the biggest trading partner of Myanmar, the second-largest trading in Thailand and Vietnam, and the biggest foreign investor in Cambodia and Laos.3 China's Digital Belt and Road Initiative seeks to place Chinese technology—of which the United States has raised concerns about high-risk vendors such as Huawei and ZTE—at the center of rapidly developing digital infrastructure worldwide. In addition, the Belt and Road Initiative brings the promise of jobs and updated infrastructure that are sorely needed in the region.

China’s Huawei is the world’s largest supplier of 5G infrastructure technology. While Lower Mekong governments seek 5G investment, they have generally not agreed to exclusive arrangements with Chinese companies. Thailand was one of the first Asia-Pacific countries to launch its own 5G network. Thailand moved quickly to reallocate spectrum for 5G and begin auctions for service providers. Similar to other Southeast Asian countries, such as Malaysia, Thailand also chose to base its 5G network on the open radio access network (ORAN) standard and courted all of the major global suppliers. Vietnam is working on a phased deployment of their 5G network while seeking to strengthen its own technology firms in hopes they will become global exporters. Vietnam's largest telecom group, the military-run mobile network operator Viettel, is already active in 11 countries serving 110 million customers.4

Bilateral Relationships

Geopolitical influences in the region are not limited to the United States and China. Tech heavyweights such as South Korea’s Samsung, Japan’s SoftBank, and Singapore’s Shopee have major economic and digital development ties to the region. Companies from other Southeast Asian nations such as Taiwan, Malaysia, Indonesia, and the Philippines are also looking for trade opportunities, market share, manufacturing and parts, and tech talent. Furthermore, there are significant diplomatic agreements, technical and digital development support, and cooperation frameworks between Lower Mekong countries, EU countries, and regional neighbors such as Australia, South Korea, Japan, and India. Although the strategies, agreements, or partnerships may have different amounts of aid and investment attached, each shares a similar intent to further regional development, cooperation, connectivity, and socioeconomic growth.

Regional Cooperation

Beyond bilateral relationships, regional cooperation is facilitated by development projects and multilateral organizations. With oversight and support from the local Mekong River Commission, the governments collaborate on river maintenance projects such as flood and drought management, hydropower, and climate change. The region also works together to further collaborations and cooperation frameworks with global partners. All countries are members of the United Nations (UN), the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), and the Asian Development Bank (ADB). They are also signatories to the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership and members of China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). ASEAN helped facilitate the ASEAN-Mekong Basin Development Cooperation (AMBDC) platform, which includes the five Lower Mekong countries and China, with the mission to “enhance the economically sound and sustainable development of the Mekong Basin.” The ADB provides loans, technical assistance, grants, and equity investments to promote social and economic development. In addition, it facilitates the Greater Mekong Subregion Economic Cooperation Program. In March 2021, the ADB issued regional priorities including upgrading and strengthening cities’ connectivity.

Citations
  1. Raymond Zhong, “Your Next iPhone Might Be Made in Vietnam. Thank the Trade War,” New York Times, July 30, 2019, source.
  2. ​​ “Intel Invests Additional $475 Million in Vietnam,” Intel, January 26, 2021, source.
  3. “Thailand’s foreign trade up 23.1 pct in 2021,” Xinhuanet, January 21, 2022, source; Phayboune Thanabouasy, “China Remains the Largest Foreign Investor in Laos,” Laotian Times, August 17, 2021, source.
  4. Richard Javad Heydarian, “SE Asia fragments on pro and anti-Huawei lines,” Asia Times, July 9, 2021, source; Matthew Strong, “Southeast Asia expands 5G to replace China as world’s factory,” Taiwan News, August 20, 2021, source.
A Closer Look at the Lower Mekong Region

Table of Contents

Close